Outcomes of cardiopulmonary resuscitation between endotracheal intubation and supraglottic airway placement for patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a meta- analysis

doi:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-6880.2019.03.004

Abstract

Abstract:

Objective

To evaluate the outcome of cardiopulmonary resuscitation for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) patients who received endotracheal intubation (ETI) or supraglottic airway (SGA) placement.

Methods

Systematic searches were conducted in Cochrane Library, PubMed, Embase, Chinese Biomedical Literature Database, China National Knowledge Infrastructure and Wanfang data to collect studies comparing ETI and SGA performed by emergency medical service system (EMSS) staff for patients with OHCA published up to September 8, 2018. Two reviewers independently screened articles according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, extracted data and evaluated the quality of the included studies. Then meta-analysis was performed using RevMan 5.3 software.

Results

Thirteen cohort studies and one randomized controlled trial with 40 063 ETI patients and 47 897 SGA patients were enrolled. Meta-analysis demonstrated that the return of spontaneous circulation [odds ratio (OR)=1.20, 95% confidence interval (CI) (1.06, 2.51), Z=2.98, P=0.003] and neurologically intact survival after hospital discharge [OR=1.09, 95%CI (1.01, 1.19), Z=2.09, P=0.04] in the ETI group were much better than those in the SGA group. However, there were no significant differences in the admission survival rate [OR=1.14, 95%CI (1.00, 1.30), Z=1.97, P=0.05] and discharge survival rate [OR=1.04, 95%CI (0.97, 1.12), Z=1.16, P=0.25] between the two groups.

Conclusion

ETI performed by EMSS staff for patients with OHCA is much better than SGA.

Key words: Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, Cardiopulmonary resuscitation, Intubation, intratracheal, Supraglottic airway

Bojin Kou, Bihua Chen, Xueli Liao, Futuan Liao, Ni Zhu, Manhong Zhou. Outcomes of cardiopulmonary resuscitation between endotracheal intubation and supraglottic airway placement for patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a meta- analysis[J]. Chinese Journal of Critical Care Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2019, 12(03): 163-168.

/ / Recommend

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://zhwzzyxzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-6880.2019.03.004

https://zhwzzyxzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/Y2019/V12/I03/163

Figures/Tables 4

References 32

1	Kleinman ME, Brennan EE, Goldberger ZD, et al. Part 5: adult basic life support and cardiopulmonary resuscitation quality: 2015 American Heart Association Guidelines Update for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care[J]. Circulation, 2015, 132 (18 Suppl 2): S414-S435.
2	Xu F, Zhang Y, Chen Y. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation training in China: current situation and future development[J]. JAMA Cardiol, 2017, 2 (5): 469-470.
3	Wampler DA, Collett L, Manifold CA, et al. Cardiac arrest survival is rare without prehospital return of spontaneous circulation[J]. Prehosp Emerg Care, 2012, 16(4): 451-455.
4	Neumar RW, Otto CW, Link MS, et al. Part 8: adult advanced cardiovascular life support: 2010 American Heart Association Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care[J]. Circulation, 2010, 122 (18 Suppl 3): S729-S767.
5	Stewart RD, Paris PM, Winter PM, et al. Field endotracheal intubation by paramedical personnel. Success rates and complications[J]. Chest, 1984, 85 (3): 341-345.
6	Hasegawa K, Hiraide A, Chang Y, et al. Association of prehospital advanced airway management with neurologic outcome and survival in patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest[J]. JAMA, 2013, 309 (3): 257-266.
7	Wang HE, Yealy DM. Out-of-hospital endotracheal in-tubation: where are we?[J]. Ann Emerg Med, 2006, 47 (6): 532-541.
8	Katz SH, Falk JL. Misplaced endotracheal tubes by paramedics in an urban emergency medical services system[J]. Ann Emerg Med, 2001, 37 (1): 32-37.
9	Jones JH, Murphy MP, Dickson RL, et al. Emergency physician-verified out-of-hospital intubation: miss rates by paramedics[J]. Acad Emerg Med, 2004, 11 (6): 707-709.
10	Wang HE, Lave JR, Sirio CA, et al. Paramedic intu-bation errors: isolated events or symptoms of larger problems?[J]. Health Aff (Millwood), 2006, 25 (2): 501-509.
11	Warner KJ, Carlbom D, Cooke CR, et al. Paramedic training for proficient prehospital endotracheal intubation[J]. Prehosp Emerg Care, 2010, 14 (1): 103-108.
12	Wang HE, Szydlo D, Stouffer JA, et al. Endotracheal intubation versus supraglottic airway insertion in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest[J]. Resuscitation, 2012, 83 (9): 1061-1066.
13	Benoit JL, Gerecht RB, Steuerwald MT, et al. Endot-racheal intubation versus supraglottic airway placement in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a meta-analysis[J]. Resuscitation, 2015 (93): 20-26.
14	McMullan J, Gerecht R, Bonomo J, et al. Airway management and out-of-hospital cardiac arrest outcome in the CARES registry[J]. Resuscitation, 2014, 85 (5): 617-622.
15	Cady CE, Weaver MD, Pirrallo RG, et al. Effect of emergency medical technician-placed combitubes on outcomes after out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest[J]. Prehosp Emerg Care, 2009, 13 (4): 495-499.
16	Hanif MA, Kaji AH, Niemann JT. Advanced airway management does not improve outcome of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest[J]. Acad Emerg Med, 2010, 17 (9): 926-931.
17	Kajino K, Iwami T, Kitamura T, et al. Comparison of supraglottic airway versus endotracheal intubation for the pre-hospital treatment of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest[J]. Crit Care, 2011, 15 (5): R236.
18	Nagao T, Kinoshita K, Sakurai A, et al. Effects of bag - mask versus advanced airway ventilation for patients undergoing prolonged cardiopulmonary resuscitation in pre - hospital setting[J]. J Emerg Med, 2012, 42 (2): 162-170.
19	Noda E, Zaitsu A, Hashizume M, et al. Prognosis of patient with cardiopulmonary arrest transported to Kyushu University Hospital[J]. Fukuoka Igaku Zasshi, 2007, 98 (3): 73-81.
20	Shin SD, Ahn KO, Song KJ, et al. Out-of-hospital airway management and cardiac arrest outcomes: a propensity score matched analysis[J]. Resuscitation, 2012, 83 (3): 313-319.
21	Tanabe S, Ogawa T, Akahane M, et al. Comparison of neurological outcome between tracheal intubation and supraglottic airway device insertion of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients: a nationwide, population-based, observational study[J]. J Emerg Med, 2013, 44 (2): 389-397.
22	Yanagawa Y, Sakamoto T. Analysis of prehospital care for cardiac arrest in an urban setting in Japan[J]. J Emerg Med, 2010, 38 (3): 340-345.
23	Kang K, Kim T, Ro YS, et al. Prehospital endotrac-heal intubation and survival after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: results from the Korean nationwide registry[J]. Am J Emerg Med, 2016, 34 (2): 128-132.
24	Park MJ, Kwon WY, Kim K, et al. Prehospital sup-raglottic airway was associated with good neurologic outcome in cardiac arrest victims especially those who received prolonged cardiopulmonary resuscitation[J]. Acad Emerg Med, 2017, 24 (12): 1464-1473.
25	Sulzgruber P, Datler P, Sterz F, et al. The impact of airway strategy on the patient outcome after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a propensity score matched analysis[J]. Eur Heart J Acute Cardiovasc Care, 2018, 7 (5): 423-431.
26	Benger JR, Kirby K, Black S, et al. Effect of a strategy of a supraglottic airway device vs tracheal intubation during out-of-hospital cardiac arrest on functional outcome: the AIRWAYS-2 randomized clinical trial[J]. JAMA, 2018, 320 (8): 779-791.
27	Vézina MC, Trépanier CA, Nicole PC, et al. Complications associated with the Esophageal-Tracheal Combitube^R in the pre-hospital setting[J]. Can J Anaesth, 2007, 54 (2): 124-128.
28	Ostermayer DG, Gausche-Hill M. Supraglottic airways: the history and current state of prehospital airway adjuncts[J]. Prehosp Emerg Care, 2014, 18 (1): 106-115.
29	Park SH, Han SH, Do SH, et al. The influence of head and neck position on the oropharyngeal leak pressure and cuff position of three supraglottic airway devices[J]. Anesth Analg, 2009, 108 (1): 112-117.
30	Segal N, Yannopoulos D, Mahoney BD, et al. Impairment of carotid artery blood flow by supraglottic airway use in a swine model of cardiac arrest[J]. Resuscitation, 2012, 83 (8): 1025-1030.
31	Studnek JR, Thestrup L, Vandeventer S, et al. The association between prehospital endotracheal intubation attempts and survival to hospital discharge among out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients[J]. Acad Emerg Med, 2010, 17 (9): 918-925.
32	江哲龙，王东升，何爱文, 等. 心肺复苏后大鼠血浆中微小核糖核酸在心肌损伤中的变化及其意义[J/CD]. 中华危重症医学杂志（电子版）, 2017, 10(5): 316-321.

[1]	Yingying Kong, Lutao Xie, Xiaochi Lu, Jiefeng Xu, Guangju Zhou, Mao Zhang. Protective effect and mechanism of sodium butyrate on cardio-brain injury after cardiac arrest resuscitation in pigs [J]. Chinese Journal of Critical Care Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2023, 16(05): 355-362.
[2]	Hengtong Lou, Yuanqiang Lu. Risk factors of prognosis in patients with non-traumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and development of a nomogram prediction model [J]. Chinese Journal of Critical Care Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2023, 16(03): 177-186.
[3]	Gannan Wang, Zhongman Zhang, Xiaoquan Xu, Nana Sun, Xufeng Chen, Jinsong Zhang. Study on the predictive value of neurological prognosis-related indicators in survivors of adult extracorporeal cardiopulmonary resuscitation [J]. Chinese Journal of Critical Care Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2022, 15(01): 9-13.
[4]	Ya Zhu, Hui Zhao, Lianlian Dong, Yan Jin. Effect of subcryogenic therapy on matrix metalloproteinase-9, neuron-specific enolase and cerebral resuscitation in rabbit brain tissue after cardiopulmonary resuscitation [J]. Chinese Journal of Critical Care Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2021, 14(05): 374-379.
[5]	Xiangpeng Liao, Rui An. Recent recommendations in 2020 Newborn Resuscitation Guidelines and Newborn Resuscitation Program (8th Edition) [J]. Chinese Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Pediatrics(Electronic Edition), 2021, 17(05): 527-535.
[6]	Shijie Gu, Lin Ma, Qiuyuan Chen, Ruiwen Cui, Baicong Lai, Xiaohong Shi, Fanhang Meng, Shuhong Yi, Ronghua Cao. Role of manual and mechanical chest compression in organ maintenance after cardiac arrest of brain-dead donors [J]. Chinese Journal of Hepatic Surgery(Electronic Edition), 2022, 11(03): 283-287.
[7]	Yang Yu, Xiaojie Liu, LiJuan Wang, Yuchen Gao, Yao Ding, Hushan Ao. Training model for cardiopulmonary resuscitation under the background of regular control of COVID-19 [J]. Chinese Journal of Clinicians(Electronic Edition), 2023, 17(04): 483-486.
[8]	Zheng Ni, Yinghua Zhu. Progress in research of video-assisted dispatcher-guided extramural cardiopulmonary resuscitation [J]. Chinese Journal of Clinicians(Electronic Edition), 2022, 16(09): 842-846.
[9]	Yixin Wang, Pingjing Zheng, Xianxiong Huang, Yang Bai, Guoguo Du, Hua Zhang. Intention of bystanders to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a review [J]. Chinese Journal of Clinicians(Electronic Edition), 2022, 16(09): 828-832.
[10]	Donglan Mei, Shouyi Ling, Bing Mei, Guangliang Shao, Zhihui Sun. Application value of sequential pre-hospital automatic cardiopulmonary resuscitation machine and marrow infusion in rescuing patients with cardiac arrest [J]. Chinese Journal of Hygiene Rescue(Electronic Edition), 2023, 09(03): 159-162.
[11]	Nan Zhang, Xueli Sheng, Jun Shao, Shiyuan Fang, Fang Wang, Xian Zhu, Binjie Zhou. Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients with prehospital recovery of spontaneous circulation: an epidemiological study [J]. Chinese Journal of Hygiene Rescue(Electronic Edition), 2022, 08(06): 326-330.
[12]	Yong Jin, Gang Chen, Zhihong Shen, Xiaoqin Li. Prediction of cardiopulmonary resuscitation in patients with pre-hospital cardiac arrest by first-aid time [J]. Chinese Journal of Hygiene Rescue(Electronic Edition), 2021, 07(06): 338-341.
[13]	Congsheng Li, Jing Yang, Yong Wang, Yuyu Hao. Clinical application of abdominal lifting and compression cardiopulmonary resuscitation for treatment of patients with cardiac arrest [J]. Chinese Journal of Hygiene Rescue(Electronic Edition), 2021, 07(05): 269-271.
[14]	Zixian Wu, Simin Yang, Baochun Zhou. Advance in predicting neurological outcome of patients with post-cardiac arrest syndrome [J]. Chinese Journal of Cerebrovascular Diseases(Electronic Edition), 2022, 16(03): 202-205.
[15]	Zhenzhong Li, Liqun Feng, Qingbian Ma, Tao Wang, Yongqiu Li, Bin Zhao, Xiuchuan Qin, Qingxi Li, Shizheng Wu, Hongbin Sun, Jun Yuan, Lan Chu, Jian Wu, Yuxiang Gu, Jimao Peng, Zhi Chen, Dongsheng Fan. Interpretation of 2020 expert consensus statement on neuroprotection after cardiac arrest in China (Ⅲ): drug therapy [J]. Chinese Journal of Cerebrovascular Diseases(Electronic Edition), 2021, 15(06): 356-360.

Please choose a citation manager

Content to export